In the thick of autumn, as the leaves in the upper echelons of the Himalayas were turning, with a sense of spectacle, into bright oranges and reds, I embarked on a three-day hiking tour in Har-ki-Dun, a valley nestled in the hills of Garhwal. On the second day, I had an encounter with a musk deer, immortalized in a couplet of Kabir. I had left the base camp with a few hikers, but they had gotten ahead, and I was by myself when I turned a corner and saw him. More than his distinct, heady scent, his eyes as he met mine, captured my attention.
In one of his essays, John Berger had described that the experience of witnessing an animal in its habitat can fill you with a profound sense of loneliness because the beast reveals a harmonious union with the natural world—a union that you, as a spectator and passerby, are excluded from. As I met the gaze of the deer who wasn’t skittish—he seemed in no particular rush to break eye contact, in fact—I felt that profound loneliness that Berger speaks of.
That day, as I left the deer behind and continued my hike, a distinct image came to me, one that had no traces of my surroundings or my encounter: a young man transfers a picture from one wall to another, locks the door to his house and leaves with nothing more than the clothes he’s wearing.
Upon returning to the guest house, I had the impulse to journal from his perspective. My writing led me to a certain kind of reason: he was transferring a picture from the wall that, in his house, had pictures of the living, to the one that had pictures of the dead. But where was he going, and was it the death of a loved one that spurred him on? I didn’t have an answer.
There was no casual thread connecting the image to what came before it or to what comes after. And as Oscar Wilde notes, all story is causality: ‘there lived a king and a queen, the king died and the queen died’ is not a story; but add causality: ‘there lived a king and a queen, he went to a war that claimed his life and then she died of heartbreak’, and you have a living, throbbing story.
I decided to set my journal aside for now.